Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Sidewinders Bar & Grille' started by dogletnoir, Apr 7, 2018.
Timing is feel. You have to internalize it...
Working on that
No, you're not nuts.
There were actually some reasons why i didn't include a lead sheet for this tune in the OP.
First, not everyone around here can read music.
Second, jazz has a tradition of oral/aural learning apart from reading charts.
Third (and most importantly imo), you need to fit the melody to the backing track
in the same way that the melody is handled in a slightly different manner for
each of the versions posted in the thread.
Being able to use your ears and nailing a particular rhythmic feel are vital parts of the skill set.
It's a pretty straightforward melody, and i was really hoping that most people would learn it by ear.
i didn't look at the chart myself.
My first intention was to transcribe it but then I saw the sheet and I knew how much time I would have to spend on getting the timing right, so I took the easy way out. It took me around 20 minutes to learn the head up to speed tapping my foot, but as soon as I start using a metronome or the track I screw up royally. I've now spent a total of around eight hours just trying to play on the beat to a metronome and it's slowly, slowly getting there. I think this might actually be something you could put a diagnosis on.
8 hours? my diagnosis is you suffer from a cornucopia of devotion
I'm known to be stubborn. A while ago I was playing in the sofa nd my girlfriend said "I'm really impressed, most people would have given up long ago".
She meant well but it didn't feel like it
You (the general "you" as in everyone) can be your own worst enemy. Listen to the music. Go to the music and try to play it. Count. Tap your foot. Sing it first. If you can sing it, you can play it. Take your time. Don't think....feel.
i spent some time this morning getting a feel for the solo -this is my first take after goofing around for a couple of hours ( a couple of takes got tossed because i accidentally solo'd in the 5th chorus).... really all i have are some key notes to make you think i hit the modes the way i as supposed to (major 3rd and flattened 7th over the F7 so you'd think i went all mixolydian, etc) even with tons of mistakes, i assure i was playing very cautiously... i thought about waiting to post when i was famous and knew what i was doing, but then realized we don't have that many lifetimes left on this planet probably
That's great Monte. Timing is loose...a little behind. Like the blues.
On the nose. There's that octave funky rhythm part that made me play the head a little differently than I normally do. If I could mix the backer, I'd kill that part altogether. LOL
I have a moment before rehearsal....
Yes jazz has an aural tradition.
But almost all of the masters could and did read music, even if it was often just to notate a new head for a recording session or for use as a lead sheet for copyright purposes.
Of course the big bands had charts and the arranger was an important role.
Indeed , many jazz performances do not exactly match the sheet music! So you do need to use your ears.
"First, not everyone around here can read music."
In my opinion that needs correcting.
As far as I am concerned, you NEED to be able to read music. Most of us do not have the ear skills of a Wes Montgomery.
Maybe not sight read at pro gig level - but be able to read a chart in the "Real Book" or whatever is an absolute MUST when I am teaching.
ALL of my jazz teachers REQUIRED music reading as a part of the learning process. That includes Ellis Marsalis...and the last time I saw his band play, not a sheet of music was on the bandstand.
Until they played a "new" chart, and they pulled out the parts and read them happily.
Now it gets fun - a lot of charts are not written correctly, and then you have to make changes to "correct" them.
Anyway, keep up the good work, I'll check in later today after the rehearsals.
None of the bands play exactly like the first sheet music.
Did you look at the other attachment?
This version I found later.
I think it would be better if I will shut up and just play until I get at least basic understanding.
Hopefully not the last, unless you ban me lol.
One take, one go, no multi-tracks.
The point of the thread is to learn. Just playing, without studying, asking questions, or working, isn't productive for anyone.
There are threads for jamming. Posting a track and getting people to hear/listen to you play.
This thread is to learn how to fit into a specific bag: jazz.
So, if you want to learn something about playing jazz, or share something you've learned about playing jazz, this is the thread for that. If you just want to post a track, and not participate in the discussion, well what's the point of that?
Do I have to do something different after the solo other than repeating head’s riff? Harmony part is the name?
Wow you are coming along Omar!!!!!
What @fezz parka said. I feel the beat, I hate metronomes. It comes naturally with repetition. You can do it
Thank you! practice makes perfect and of course everyone’s support