Well I figured as much.... but has Reverb put a hold on the funds in Paypal? Or have you pulled the funds out already? If Reverb has already refunded his money, they will certainly try to get it back from you, or they will be closing your account. And I read the buyer's feedback --and yeah, that's on him (and probably not a good idea on his part). But I guess you have to consider the buyer's side in this as well: he paid you in good faith for a beautiful guitar but got a broken guitar instead, and then you refused to give him a refund, correct? I mean, no matter how you slice it, any sold item is always the seller's responsibility until delivered w/o issues to the buyer, and obviously that didn't happen in this case. Again, sorry you're dealing with this, but your blame for what's happened is misplaced if you are putting it on the buyer.