My deductive reasoning: You have two maple boards, so I figure you like maple. You have two bursts, so I figure you like burst. So, when I put the maple, with the burst, I deduce you will keep No. 1, or the one furthest left in the photo. Since my son has been binge watching Sherlock Holmes shows, I figured I'd make an attempt at bein' smartererer. Of course, then there is the potential "trick question" aspect of your post, but since I'm not that smartererer, I'll stick with No. 1.
I never base the decision of "which Strat" solely on looks alone so unless I can play them I can't guess.
Middle, because you've come to your senses and realized the aesthetic, tonal and sensory superiority of rosewood over maple.