I’m going to “black top” one of my LPs

Is that the actual guitar you have? The one at the top? If it is, I think it looks really nice, would be a shame to hide it behind a black wall, but it’s your Choice of course

 

In this case, yes, black.

 

I prefer the yellowy finish to black as well. Could potentially prefer black if it was matte.

https://images.app.goo.gl/ezK9SznKfNaa6JYY7

 

Me too, lot more cool in yellow flame imo.. btw is it a Gibson?
Very beautiful

 

Nooooo

 

Nah, don't hide this beautiful flamed maple....

You might wan to just refinish it with a more transparent lacquer... You'd have to check if it's a cap or a veneer... with a veneer you won't have much sanding material.

 

With that beautiful grain, I think I'd opt to sand off the current orange stain and then restain with a translucent color of choice and clear coat. Covering that pretty wood in black paint would be a bummer. Just my .02.

 

Did you just spray right over the already gloss finish?

 

I do hope you scrape the paint off the binding though. The look is not gonna work otherwise.

I quite like red tops and black tops with a brown back. In fact, any of Gibson's non-trans finishes would work better on a Les Paul if they kept the back and sides trans-brown like on a Goldtop. I never understood why Gibson won't do more of these Gretsch-like schemes.

 

That's some nice maple. I wouldn't cover it up. How about changing it to wine red?

EDIT: Oh, just noticed you already painted it. Carry on.

 

You gonna put metal covers on the HBs and mount a cream pickguard to complete the look?

 

I am/was in the leave the yellow flame top. But if it floats yer boat thats okay.

P.S. I like black guitars and it looks good… but the yellow was nice…

 

Do you need me to come over there and talk you down?

 

Holy crap, I saw youre doing it. Youd better come over and talk me down off my roof.

 

Yeah, nah.

The light back ruins the look.
paint the back and scrape the binding properly.