Why don’t we like active electronics in a guitar?

Electgumbo

Not Of This Earth
Dec 26, 2010
12,102
Scott, La.
I build my own preamp with treble and bass boost and cut back in the early 80’s. I used it for years. It ran on 18 volts and was a heck of a contraption. It was called a Craig Anderson Clarifier and was in a GP magazine with Frank Zappa on the cover. I drilled and etched the board and every thing.

I would put EMG’s in my other guitars so they could almost keep up with my Strat with my home made preamp in it. My Focus 6000 Kramer still has EMG’s in it from the 80’s.

You can see the wire running to the guitar strap where the batteries are in the photo from under the pick guard ….. this is 84 or 1985…

409313AC-55C3-46FB-A531-00E1E87180A7.jpeg
 
Last edited:

train

Senior Stratmaster
Silver Member
Jan 22, 2015
1,068
Usa.
Like the pre-amp on acoustics. Sounds good , you should build it. Then review it here. Strat only
 

vid1900

Most Honored Senior Member
Nov 25, 2016
9,492
Yemen
Just about every bass player has active controls

But as far as guitar, the only active one commonly seen is the Crapton strat
 

bigreen505

Strat-Talk Member
Jul 5, 2021
53
Colorado
Same. I do love EMG pickups but something about having a battery in my guitar seems wrong.

I need to give EMG pickups another shake. Maybe they've changed. Maybe I've changed. In high school, I had a Les Paul with an EMG 85(?) in the bridge. I had a guitar teacher with a strat with the same pickup. The two guitars sounded identical. That was my first strike against active electronics. Maybe I can go buy a Peavey Predator, throw in EMGs and have a great sounding guitar. I don't know.

Around the same time I was also interested in an Eric Clapton strat. It had a cool sound and could push an amp much like a humbucker, but it had an odd, compressed, processed sound. How much of that was the electronics and how much was the Lace Sensor pickups I can't say. I really wanted the guitar but it had a feel I didn't like that none of the traditional pickup/passive electronics guitars had. Strike two.

Recently I found a deal on an EBMM Cutlass. I loved the feel of the guitar. Loved the neck. The action was lower than I like, but that's easy to fix. When I plugged it in, the guitar had a sterile, brittle sound that I couldn't get past. I played a few other guitars that day. One was a ... I'm blanking on the name .. gold signature strat with Dimarzios and active electronics made for a Christian Music guy. Same problem. I also played a Custom Shop Telecaster and a PRS Silver Sky and they both sounded amazing. Strike three.

So why is it that I think active electronics in a guitar is a bad idea, but moving those same electronics to a box on the floor is a good thing? I wish I knew. Maybe it's because the box on the floor I can bypass.
 

StratoMutt

Most Honored Senior Member
Mar 15, 2019
8,993
SE Pennsylvania
Q: Why don’t we like active electronics in a guitar?

A: I like simple and traditional. No transistors.

Had a Japanese Charvel P J bass in the late 90s that a previous owner installed EMGs. I liked them well enough and only had to put a battery in it once in two years.
 

systolsys

Strat-O-Master
Nov 22, 2020
969
Sydney, Australia
Personal preference. Mainly for the same reason I don't like bluetooth headphones or wireless computer keyboards... One more thing to charge or have batteries for. A cable does the job better and cheaper. Innovation for the sake of innovation doesn't always produce a better result.

I've been happy with passive pickups going into a Boss EQ for sound tweaking and boost. But I'm not running around on stage needing to make on the fly changes to sound mid-playing.

I find the classic active humbuckers are pretty boring. EMG sets have a use, but it's not anything I need. I like metal, but I get what a want with a JB or even a 59/Custom.

But electronics attached to a preamp on an acoustic, or piezo-electrics are different. And my bass has active pickups. Not by design... it just happened to be the one I bought.

I will admit the battery compartment on my Roadhouse (now fitted with a Delta tone circuit) is really useful for storing picks.
 

Dreamdancer

Senior Stratmaster
May 1, 2014
2,362
Greece
I like the sound of actives, the only thing i dont like is the battery...but thats why i dont like laptops either....lately though i have always thought that the new backplate battery thingy from fishman seems a lot cooler and actually acts like a cell phone being charged.I could live with something like that.
 

Impulsive guppy

Senior Stratmaster
Gold Supporting Member
Jan 9, 2020
1,095
Springfield
I really like the Alembic Blaster. It’s sort of a boost.
The battery lasts a very long time, well made.


alembic_2196_3590609
 

CalicoSkies

Most Honored Senior Member
Gold Supporting Member
Jun 10, 2013
6,873
Beaverton, OR, USA
Who are "we"? It seems to me that there are enough people who like active electronics in guitars.
I tend not to like active electronics in guitars though. I mainly don't want to worry about my guitar no longer working due to a dead battery that needs to be replaced/recharged.

I tend to prefer not to have batteries in things in general if it's not really needed. With a computer, I tend to prefer a wired mouse & keyboard rather than having a battery-powered wireless keyboard & mouse, so that I don't have to worry about replacing batteries (and besides, I'm always at my computer desk when using my PC, so I don't need to take the mouse & keyboard far away). I also don't mind plugging headphones into a device if it means not worrying about headphone batteries dying. Though, honestly sometimes it's nice not to have to worry about a headphone cable stringing down to my phone if I'm listening to music or something. There have been times when I've used wired headphones with my phone and strung the cord under my shirt so it doesn't get caught on anything, and having wireless headphones can be useful in situations like that.
 

CalicoSkies

Most Honored Senior Member
Gold Supporting Member
Jun 10, 2013
6,873
Beaverton, OR, USA
It's 9v. I put one on my Clapton and it's great.
Ah. When I think of a 9V battery, I usually think of one of these:
4556718.jpg

The person I quoted mentioned licking the new battery, and that usually refers to the type pictured above. I don't think it's as easy to get the same effect by licking one of the rechargeable trem cover batteries. :)
 


Latest posts

Top