According to that, Performer and Ultra Luxe Vintage Magnificent Oh Boy are the same thing. Only one's a lot more expensive.To assume that everyone will prefer the modern feel is a sure way to alienate huge portions of your potential buyers. It’s great that Fender offers different combinations of feel, sound and look instead of trying fit everyone in the same bucket.
Just the other day I had an exchange with someone about them not getting along with their first strat possibly because of a modern neck profile. Assume everyone prefers thinner fast necks, and some will be steered away from the brand. For instance, PRS had an obsession with pattern thin (wide thin) necks for a time. I have friends who used to say that PRS weren’t for them because their thin necks and overall profile caused their hands to cramp. Same thing with Gibson’s obsession with their 60s slim tapper necks trying to undo the reputation of chunky necks.
What Fender is doing is brilliant. Here is my interpretation:
American Performer: modern leaning feel, vintage leaning looks, vintage leaning sound
American Pro II: vintage leaning feel, vintage or modern looks depending on plastics and finish color options, modern leaning sound
American Ultra II: all modern
American Vintage II: all vintage
American Ultra Luxe Vintage: vintage looks and sound with a modern feel
Sure they could make even more granular models, but that would just confuse people. If they did took the AVii 61 and just changed a few things, like SS frets, but keep the fret size, HSS configuration, luminlay side dots, that heel carve, I’d be all over that. Particularly if they switched to full nitro without the poly sealer and offered in OW and Surf green, both with clay dots. I’d keep the vintage gunners, but those string trees of the Am Pro II are nice, so I’d use that. That’d be my perfect specs, but they’d sell two guitars to me and and that’s about. I think the model they devised with the Ultra Luxe Vintage will be more popular than this hypothetical spec list tailored for my personal taste, vintage focus with very subtle modern attributes. In this hypothetical scenario, I surmise that we’d see a lot more hate posts on social media.
We’re pretty tame here, btw. For most part I’m seeing people just expressing if this is a model for them or not. Discussions might get a little more interesting here, but outside S-T feels like the Wild West in comparison. Some people seem to have really embraced the dark side letting the hate flow through them, lol.